The following is an actual e-mail I sent earlier today (“today”, meaning “February 5, 2009” in Korea). If you’re interested in seeing what sparked it, and are on Facebook, check out my profile and see the comments regarding a posted item, “Jonathan Kay: Iraqi democracy is Bush’s true legacy”.
*******
“You know what Jeremy? I don’t think I can stomach any more of your hateful rhetoric. You’re a racist, anti-Muslim, and anti-American. I’m going to be de-friending you as soon as I post this.”
– Geoffrey Korol’s final entry in a debate on Facebook about a posted item
******
Geoff,
Did you actually read anything of what I said? Hateful rhetoric, Geoff? I am insulted at the accusation. Did you actually read the item I posted? Because, let’s be honest, I don’t think you did. You didn’t read the National Post article, you only responded to what I wrote. If you had read that article, you would understand A) Why I posted it and B) How wrong you are.
How am I racist? Do I call out “Death to Arabs”? Geoff, you know what? You’re an idiot – and I say that with all the respect I can muster at this moment, which isn’t much, because I think you’re pretty darn petty. Nowhere, not once in my postings, did I call for Arabs to be killed. I merely said, as I stated in the postings, that I don’t have to cry for all of them when they die. I even noted that I regret their deaths from a humanitarian standpoint. But never did I call for the mass slaughter of Arabs.
You attribute to me an attribute I have not, for reasons I know not. Character assassination? I don’t know why you would want to do that to me. I don’t know how I could have earned your hatred, because any reasonable person would actually read what I’ve written instead of responding to snippets or spinning what I actually wrote into words I’ve never written.
And seriously, how petty are you? Again, it is with all the respect for you I can muster: How pathetic is it than in a moment of anger, which is nothing more than anger that my opinion differs from yours, you delete me – thus attempting to cut contact – over Facebook postings? I used to think you were pretty smart, but I’ve more evidence to the contrary, now.
And where do you get off calling me anti-American? That’s really out of left field, and is the most egregious, inaccurate, insulting charge ever laid out against me. Forgive me, but I always thought that sharing my opinion is as American as it gets. DE-FRIENDING someone on Facebook who was an actual friend in high school because of his opinion amounts to…well, it’s not persecution, but it’s certainly not a celebration of diverse opinions, which is quite American.
So think about it, Geoff:
Who is anti-American: The one who would delete a Facebook (and real-life) friend because of his opinions (we’re talking about you) or the one who loves vigorous debate (me), even if – especially if – those with whom he is debating disagrees sharply with him?
Two things, Geoff:
*
First, this quote. It’s one of my favorites, by William F. Buckley, Jr.: “Liberals claim to want to give a hearing to other views, but then are shocked and offended to discover that there are other views.”
*
And second, this response from a friend of mine to my status this morning:
Yasser Kassana at 4:50am February 5 via Facebook Mobile
Inhuman is strong. I’m no fan of liberals or socialists and the like. I also know that me and you are opposing in every way. But why can’t people just talk peacefully. The problem is Avram that liberals don’t understand the other side. I understand and empathise but I will not agree with you.
My status update that Yasser was responding to was: Jeremy wonders why, when he thinks others are merely “wrong”, THEY go so far as to call him “inhuman,” or imply that he’s evil. Illiberal “liberals” need chill pills.
*
Geoff, I don’t know why you think of me the way you do, but you are absolutely wrong to do so. I don’t suspect, for a moment, that anything I wrote here will have any effect on you whatsoever. It won’t make you change your mind, which is why I haven’t tried to do such a thing. I know such an effort would be futile, because I happen to think, now, that you are as narrow-minded as you accuse me of being. Only a narrow-minded person – or a simple-minded nitwit – would jump to conclusions as you have.
Only a narrow-minded person would go so far as to sever the re-kindled links of friendship over what was said and spun in postings on a web site. Only a narrow-minded person, such as yourself, would seek to end a friendship because of a disagreement in opinion (which is what all this amounts to). Only a narrow-minded person would assume I’m anti-Muslim, especially given the fact that I own a couple copies of the Qu’ran, and have lived around Muslims longer than you have. That’s an assumption, yes, but I would like to know how many mosques you’ve visited.
And, Geoff, let’s get back to the unforgivable part: Only a narrow-minded, conniving person would stoop to calling me “anti-American” without any supporting evidence. I’m not sure what’s pro-American to you, but to me, the right to speak one’s mind out – without persecution – is as American as it gets. When I spent 3 months in 2007 living in the DC area, I visited the National Archives 2-3 times a week, just to see again what I’d already seen many, many times before: The Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights…
I don’t pick and choose the moments I’m patriotic, Geoff, as I suspect you do. I love my country 24/7, 365 (or, “24/7, 366” on the occasion of a leap year). I acknowledge its faults, and its mistakes. I criticize my country and my Government when I feel both are deserving of admonishment. How you, with the evidence pointing to you being a fair-weather patriot despite your service, can come up with the charge that I’m anti-American is a mystery to me.
Should you ever unclench your fist, Geoff, you will not find I’m inclined to shake it. You were an actual friend, a real-life friend. No more, and not because you Facebook de-friended me. You made narrow-minded assumptions about me, and you jumped to conclusions, and you publicly charged me with being things that I’m not. Then, you didn’t give me a chance to respond to your libels. That’s about as low as you can go in my book; you calling me “inhuman” I was willing to overlook.
Then you went too far.
Just in case you’re tempted to twist my words into something they aren’t, I’m think I’m going to post this online – which I have the right to do, free speech and all – as a sort of “open letter” opinion piece on my blog. Not because I want your friendship back. But because I want others to know that you are so utterly undeserving of my friendship. You accused me of being racist, anti-Muslim and anti-American, and then you displayed disrespect and cowardice by running off (so to speak).
I’d tell you to go to Hell, but you don’t believe in Heaven. So I’ll just settle for, “Go fuck yourself.”
Kindest regards,
J.S. Slavin